The short answer: Moving from New York to Florida usually gets you more house, more space and no snow to shovel. The trade-offs are a car-based life, HOA rules, and a few Florida surprises. Start with a map call, so you pick the right side of town before you pick a house.
Moving from New York to Florida is a big jump, and Central Florida is one of the places New Yorkers land most. I have helped people buy homes here full time since 2001. Here's what changes when you trade New York for the Orlando, Kissimmee and St. Cloud area, from what I see with buyers every week.
You Won't Be Alone Down Here
The good news first. You won't be the only New Yorker on the block. A lot of people from New York already live in Central Florida. Most folks here are friendly. And yes, you can still find New York style pizza.
Not everyone comes from the city, either. Plenty of people move here from the suburbs or the country. Wherever you come from, two things change fast. There's no snow to shovel. And there are no deer jumping in front of your car on the way home.
You don't give up city life, either. Orlando has top-end shopping, dining and entertainment, and most of it is a short drive away.
Planning a move from New York? Book a 15-minute call with me or call or text (321) 320-7129.
What Your Money Buys Here
Most New York buyers are surprised by how much home they get here. More space. A yard. A garage. Newer homes with community pools, gyms and walking paths close by. In St. Cloud, even lake frontage or a few acres of land.
How much more depends on where you're coming from and where you land. A buyer selling a home on Long Island sees it differently than a renter from Queens. And the same budget buys very different homes on each side of the county line. I break that down in my guide to how much more house you get in St. Cloud than in Orlando.
HOAs Are New to Most New Yorkers
Here's the one I explain on almost every call. Most newer communities here have a homeowners association, or HOA. Many New Yorkers have never lived with one, and at first it sounds like a bad thing.
An HOA runs the shared parts of a community. It keeps up the pools, the parks and the front entrance. It also sets rules for what you can do with your home and your street.
Not all HOAs are alike. Some are very strict. They care about your fence, your paint color and where you park your truck. Others are pretty hands-off. The right one depends on how you want to live. Read the rules before you sign, not after you move in.
Many new communities also have a CDD fee, which shows up on your property tax bill. Coming from New Jersey? Read how the tax bill works when moving from New Jersey to Florida. I explain both in my guide to HOA vs. CDD fees in Florida. From California? A CDD works a lot like Mello-Roos, as I explain in my guide to moving from California to Florida.
Cars, Commutes and Tolls
If you're coming from the city, this is the biggest change. Here, you drive almost everywhere.
A New York family recently asked online whether St. Cloud traffic is as bad as people say. My honest answer: it depends on where you're going.
- Heading north at rush hour from Narcoossee Road toward Lake Nona, Orlando or the airport can be frustrating. Most people jump on the 417 or the Turnpike.
- Expect delays. It's lighter than New York traffic, but in my experience, an extra 20 to 25 minutes at peak times is normal.
- Leave at least 30 minutes early if you drive during 9-to-5 rush hours. On a normal day, most of St. Cloud is about 30 minutes from Orlando.
- Tolls are a choice. We have toll roads, a lot like New York. But you don't have to use them. I-4 and regular roads will get you there too.
- School traffic is real. Families here choose between public, charter and private schools. Many parents drive their kids instead of using the bus, so roads fill up at drop-off and pickup time.
Part of the reason is growth. Osceola County, home to St. Cloud and Kissimmee, has been the fastest-growing county in Central Florida for years, based on U.S. Census estimates. New homes mean new drivers.
One more thing for drivers: once you live here, you have 30 days to get a Florida driver's license. Register your car and get Florida car insurance soon after you move. The Florida DHSMV new resident page lists what to bring.
Building a New Home From Up North
A lot of New Yorkers want a brand-new home. Here's what surprises them most.
The model home is the best version
The model you walk through is fully upgraded. It's decorated with every option the builder offers, so you'll want it. The base price usually doesn't include most of what you see.
How the price works
In a builder community, the price usually includes the lot. Some lots cost extra, like a lake view or a bigger yard. A spec home, one the builder has already started or finished, includes the lot, but you take it as it is. If you build custom on land you buy yourself, the land is a separate price, plus the house, plus any extras you add.
How long it takes
A custom build can take 6 to 9 months or longer, depending on the builder. Builders take a sizable deposit up front. You get pre-qualified when you first meet the builder. But your final loan terms are set close to the end, often about 30 days before closing. Builders do offer incentives that can lower your payment. They vary by builder, and they can change before you close. I explain that risk in my guide to buying a Florida home before or after you move.
The tax bill that changes later
Your first property tax bill may cover only the land. The full bill, with the house, usually shows up a year or two later. Plan for it now so it doesn't catch you off guard.
Once Florida is your full-time home, file for the homestead exemption, a property tax break I explain in my guide for New Jersey buyers moving to Florida.
You can close from New York
Fly down, find the home, and sign with the builder with your own agent beside you. When it's done, you can close from New York. You don't have to fly back, though being here when your new home is ready is exciting.
Hire your own inspector
Even a brand-new home needs a second set of eyes. Hire an independent inspector who doesn't work for the builder. See where to look first in my guide to new homes in St. Cloud.
Looking at new homes from New York?
I call the builders before you visit, so you walk in knowing what's available and what they're offering.
St. Cloud or the Orlando Side?
This decision comes down to what you want most. Here's how I'd sort it:
- More space and land: St. Cloud. You can find 5-acre and even 20-acre parcels here, room for a farm or animals, and lakefront homes. See my guide to buying land in St. Cloud.
- Luxury: The Orlando side has more of it, depending on your budget.
- Close to the airport and the hospitals: Lake Nona is the medical and research hub near Orlando International Airport. Homes there sit closer together.
- Walk to shops, work and parks: Places like Celebration, Baldwin Park and Avalon Park put homes, shops, offices and parks close together. A lot of New York buyers like that feel.
Florida Life Nobody Tells You About
Most new homes don't come with a pool
Many people from up north think every Florida house has a pool. It doesn't. In new communities, a private pool is an upgrade, more of a luxury. Instead, most new communities have shared pools, gyms, dog parks, playgrounds and clubhouses. They're built so people get out and get to know their neighbors.
The screened lanai
A covered patio, called a lanai, often has a screen enclosure. It keeps out leaves, birds and bugs. You can enjoy a Florida sunset without running inside when the bugs come out.
Alligators were here first
Alligators live in our ponds and lakes, and they're everywhere. Don't feed them. Don't go near them. It's against Florida law to feed a wild alligator. Newcomers sometimes think it's cute. But a fed gator loses its fear of people, and it can be removed as a nuisance. You can learn more from the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission.
The good wildlife, and the not-so-good
Watch for fire ants in the grass. Watch the sky for the birds. We have an amazing number of beautiful ones. On launch days, you can often see rockets from the Space Coast climb across the sky.
Two coasts
Central Florida gives you the best of both worlds. You can head to the Atlantic or the Gulf for a beach day.
Your First Step: Look at the Map With Me
Before we look at a single house, we look at the map together on Zoom. We go over:
- Where you'll work, and the traffic between there and home
- How close together you want the homes to be
- Which school type you want: public, charter or private
- Your kids' sports and activities
- Your budget
That tells us which side of town fits you. Then I narrow the homes down.
Here's what you get that a builder's sales rep won't give you. The friendly rep in the model home is paid by the builder, and their job is to sell that builder's homes. My job is to get you the right one. I call the builders before you visit to find homes that are ready sooner and what's being offered. I make sure you have your own inspector. And I don't hand you off to a team. You get a staff of people helping along the way, but every negotiation and every contract goes through me personally. See how I work with buyers on my St. Cloud buyer's agent page, or read my full Moving to Central Florida guide.
Moving from New York?
Book a 15-minute call. We'll look at the map together, and I'll tell you which side of town fits how you want to live.
Frequently Asked Questions
How soon do I need a Florida driver's license after moving from New York?
Within 30 days of becoming a Florida resident. Register your car and get Florida car insurance soon after you move. The Florida DHSMV new resident page lists what to bring.
Is St. Cloud traffic as bad as people say?
It depends on where you're going. Heading north toward Orlando or the airport at rush hour, I tell buyers to expect an extra 20 to 25 minutes. Leave at least 30 minutes early. It's still lighter than New York traffic.
Do most Florida homes come with a pool?
No. In new communities, a private pool is usually an upgrade. Most new communities have shared pools, gyms and parks instead.
Can I buy a Florida home and close without flying back from New York?
Yes. You can close remotely with a mobile notary or online notarization if your lender agrees. You don't have to fly back for closing.
Do I need my own agent when I buy from a builder?
The builder's sales rep works for the builder. Your own agent works for you, calls the builders ahead of time, and makes sure you have an independent inspector. Bring your agent on your first visit, since some builders won't add an agent later.
Is it legal to feed alligators in Florida?
No. Feeding a wild alligator is against Florida law. A fed gator loses its fear of people and can be removed as a nuisance.
Cliff Clover, REALTOR® | The Clover Group at eXp Realty, LLC | (321) 320-7129 | Serving Central Florida since 2001. This post is general information and my own experience, not legal, tax, lending or financial advice. Drive times are my own experience and vary by route and time of day.